Are we racists?
71 Star
Share This Post
Rhapsodysinger , India: Mar 7 2008
Made Popular Mar 7 2008

shahrush with emami

Our girls are badgered day in and out by multi-national companies to become fairer ad infinitum. And guys too are now targeted. Duskiness is hated and derided. Open any marriage columns in news-papers and you will find the requirement from would be brides: they have to be fair and slim and convent educated. It is passé to say that English-medium education is the most coveted education that one can provide to an Indian kid today. There are thousands of Spoken-English schools all over the land. In short, we have to become brown sahibs. All this when the British are turning to the curry for joy!

emami

Here are some harrowing experiences:

a)Young man enters an up market restaurant in Kolkata, the guards ask him to leave. His faults? He wears slippers, is unshaven and the sin of all sins: he is dark. Luckily his girl-friend inside is dressed properly for the restaurant. She is fair and beautiful. She comes to the rescue of that young man, her future husband, and they leave the restaurant in bitterness. Black suited sahibs did not allow brown people in casuals. But while they come out they see a white woman in shorts, slippers and a T-shirt being welcomed in. Have you noticed something: hotel-staff speak only in English? And even the visitors go along with that. I am not speaking about those instances when there may be a language problem, but even when both the staff and the visitors have the same vernacular.

b)Same couple visits a chain-book store in Kolkata regularly. The owners run hotels also. Mr. M there is very polite and helpful. Natty fair lady in specs breathes fire on any Indian who comes with her purse into the shop. Fine. Natty lady hates guys with bags entering the shop. Leave your bags on the security desk. Fine. Only thing, whites enter with whatever they choose. And natty lady is pleased as punch. When complained, natty lady did not bother replying to such hoi polloi. The couple does not go there any more. Mr.M’s is sidelined because he is fat, dark and only a native. People have to ask for Bengali books in English there. Such are the levels of sophistication in our country.

c)A study facility for students by a Foreign Embassy in Kolkata. Yours truly and other blackie Indians have to be searched like animals before entry into the library. The guards are rude and the Indian staff at the reception hate talking in anything but English even with people who do not know the language. White nationals have no such checks. They come and go while we in our own country stand gaping. When complaints pour in, some Indian crony mumbles: it is all about security, you know. And if too much protests happen, then just get lost. So yours truly avoids the said library. How many places to avoid?

d)Old lady thrown out of a Tata bastion. She is not fair enough; she is just Indian; she is wearing slippers. Taj Mumbai is in India, but is it for Indians?

Alas! The shame of being a South East Asian and being condemned for being one by one’s sisters and brothers. I have had the same experience in Pakistan, Nepal and Dhaka. We equate beauty with skin-color.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Manual Upload
Sorry, no media found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
-1 Stars
Sujay Aryan
rohru/shimla, India
this article looks more an advertisement despite of story of our racism nature.
you can be right to some extent but it is not always right.
it is human nature
3 Stars
I chose those ad pics to prove the point that we are indeed badgered about becoming increasingly fair and celebrities are endorsing this! Also it is human nature to be greedy, angry, murderous and jealous. Does being human pardon these. And what is not right? Dark people have a problem everywhere down the line unless folks can make out that the former are loaded. Read the agony aunt columns of every single mag, people are complaining of being dark and they all want to become fair. That is how Emami thrives. The ad is highlighted here to prove how omniscient color prejudice is in our country and sub-continent.
3 Stars
Swati S
Shimla, India
YEP....thats going on everywhere...

I would say a very fair post...and no doubts it is nothing but the truth...
3 Stars
Prince Campbell
New York, United States
Wow. I didn’t realize the racism in India.

The fact that it is allowed without complaint is crazy. Try that in the USA and the company would get sued. Money is a big incentive to treat people fairly.
-1 Stars
Sumit
Agra, India
Is this real definition of racism? Have you gone mad? get some brain dude.
3 Stars
@ sumit
Pray then, what is racism?
0 Stars
Sanyog
Chennai, India
Rahpsodysinger, I suggest you to go for a tour of South India, no body demands fair bride and groom in matrimonial. I think you are based in north India. and most importnat...don't call it racism but inferior and superior complex. Racism has a wide meaning and you shouldn't fit the word in Indian context.
-1 Stars
Prasad
Howrah, India
How can you say it racism moron? It might be your opinion and every fool has his own opinion and he can fight for that but it can't be always truth. You are abusing all Indians and why are you hiding your original name? I can understand the reason.
-1 Stars
Manishkumar
Kottayam, India
you are more endorsing fair & lovely than writing an article on racism. What a link!!! I am shockingly surprised and I would see your words even my dream.
3 Stars
I am not abusing all Indians...why don’t u visit the USIS library and see what they do? Why don’t you peek in at Jong’s at park Street? & how wud you answer for the person who got kicked from the Taj, Mumbai?
& unless people like you protest, things will be like that...it is not an Indian only phenomena...
The reason why I use the pseudonym is because I choose to do so , you wud never know who I really am had I simply used a name like Prasad...by my name I want to protest the death of the net as a free place ...
3 Stars
there are two races in India today:

the fair, the beautiful, the suave who are the rich and powerful

the ugly, dirty, the illiterate and the poor, powerless...

Unless we take stock of our own we can never change our nation’s lot...because we are a great nation amongst the fools there are wise men who can stomach criticism. Instead of criticizing others, we have to help ourselves...
-1 Stars
Sumit
Agra, India
Specially for Rahsodysinger - According to the Oxford English Dictionary, racism is a belief or ideology that all members of each race possess characteristics or abilities specific to that race, especially to distinguish it as being either superior or inferior to another race or races.

The Merriam-Webster's Dictionary defines racism as a belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race, and that it is also the prejudice based on such a belief.

The Macquarie Dictionary defines racism as 'the belief that human races have distinctive characteristics which determine their respective cultures, usually involving the idea that one's own race is superior and has the right to rule or dominate.'

According to UN International Conventions, the term 'racial discrimination" shall mean any distinction, exclusion, restriction or preference based on race, colour, descent, or national or ethnic origin which has the purpose or effect of nullifying or impairing the recognition, enjoyment or exercise, on an equal footing, of human rights and fundamental freedoms in the political, economic, social, cultural or any other field of public life.'

Racism has existed throughout human history. It may be defined as the hatred of one person by another -- or the belief that another person is less than human -- because of skin color, language, customs, place of birth or any factor that supposedly reveals the basic nature of that person. It has influenced wars, slavery, the formation of nations, and legal codes.

Don't apply the meaning of black and skin colour in western sociological context in our Indian context because here there is no place of hatred due to skin colour but caste. Hatred due to caste exists but hatred due to skin colour doesn't exist. So, don't write such useless things in Indian context. Are you trying to become India TV on Internet? If yes then its ok, you are free to write anything because no one would take you seriously.
3 Stars
@Sumit

Man, you are all worked up with all those references...but you missed the only point relevant...definitions are end products of human phenomena...language is fluid...so what you quoted is what at a certain point of time was the definition according to a group of Western lexicographers...but instead of focussing on one word, tell me do not women get tortured for giving birth to dark babies? I know a guy, about 13, who is not loved by his parents simply because he is dark, rather his sibling 10, is loved for the fairness. Due to the nature of my profession I get to hear a lot of these sad stories. ( Oh I forgot to tell you to refer to Jesperson, Walter Ong etc.) & who buys these products? Why do people want to be fair?
0 Stars
Sumit
Agra, India
This is our social problem not racism. We Indians, (whether white or black, poor or rich), are the worst victim of inferiority complex. We have started hating our own identity. let me give you an example. One year ago I was in Delhi airport waiting for my flight to Mumbai. I was sitting in lounge and one American young was also sitting next to my seat and he was chatting with a 10-yr boy sitting next to him with his mother.

His mother was busy on his mobile phone and the American and the Indian boy were chatting interesting things and I was the single audience there. The American was a professional photographer and had come to India to visit north Indian temples and Himalayan region. He was visible lookin very much impressed with Indian culture and traditions. He was praising India, Indian people, Indian cities every thing.

At the same time, the young boy, whose father was NRI living in New York, was looking excited because he was going to take International flight to New York for the first time.

During the discussion, the boy was surprisingly abusing Indian people, talking badly about Indian roads, poverty and praising US cities culture. What we (me and the American guy) felt that the boy hated India and loved US. Finally the irritated American asked the boy in strong words - "WHO TOLD YOU ALL THESE STUPID THINGS , DON'T YOU HAVE RESPECT FOR YOUR OWN COUNTRY?" The boy answered - 'My father'. The American literally shouted - "YOU FATHER IS A BIG BULL-SHIT AND YOU ARE BULL-SHIT IN MAKING".

We Indians more abuse than love our Indianness thats what you are doing here by linking the fair-dark discussion in Indian context with RACISM... I won't say anything now.
3 Stars
well, i retract if I sound putting my nation down...i have much to learn...I shall hold my peace...
3 Stars
as i said: my intentions have not been to put my country down...I only want to say that the lady at the Taj had a similar experience as I...& when I had posted a different version of this in my own blog, earlier, some Indians had not disagreed...
as for what foreigners think of us does not matter, for they are unimportant...
3 Stars
as i said: my intentions have not been to put my country down...I only want to say that the lady at the Taj had a similar experience as I...& when I had posted a different version of this in my own blog, earlier, some Indians had not disagreed...
as for what foreigners think of us does not matter, for they are unimportant...
& again I have mentioned only those of us in specific situations...
3 Stars
lastly, before i do not comment further on this post; there are a few things I want to make clear:

a) I ask the question, not provide an answer...I think we are partly racist, being casteist et al...

b) I love my people and being an Indian and feel hurt when I read about that lady at the Taj, be searched like a thief and when I read of a dusky woman writing to know how to be fair

c) My country is great and I care hoots for whether racism exists elsewhere, whether class structures exist elsewhere...we can reform and change ourselves...we can...not like where Prince comes from...

in the US people have to sue...here the awakening can come from within...

again if I have hurt anyone, it is only to show my concern for my own country and not to give a chance to foreigners to deride us...adios on this post

Lastly, i stand abashed...
-2 Stars
Sumit
Agra, India
what skin color r u, descendant of a long lost earthworm? u deserve a good hiding for writing this poo-yellow shit. instablogs must investigate his origin. I AM SERIOUS MAN!

looks like a p.w. botha worm planted in india.
3 Stars
What'sinaname?
Jaipur, India
I must say this is the most daring article i have ever read...
@Rhapsodysinger-Well if you write the truth, you have to face a lot of criticism. People do not like horrifying truths, it’s human nature...not a good one though.
@manishkumar- The picture just tells we Indians cannot face the fact that we are BLACK. Can’t you understand even that, fat-head????
4 Stars
Nightcrawler
mumbai, India
Congratulations!!!Very few would have the guts to write about racism in India the way you have done...
For Sumit- I believe all your definitions are copied from wikipedia, but may be you didn’t have the time to read the whole article. So i would advise you to pay attention to the first few lines written over there- ”Racism has many definitions, the most common and widely accepted being that members of one race consider themselves intrinsically superior to members of other races.”
The story you wrote about that American photographer may be true,but there’s one thing i should add. foreigners see India from one perspective:they live in luxurious hotels, travel by car and bla bla.They don’t have to face water crisis or power cuts or any of the millions of problems that an average Indian has to deal with.You can’t deny this.And Westerners would like us to be happy the way we are, so that we can never rise above them.
Finally i would say, racism is thriving in India(more and more demand for cosmetics like fair n lovely proves that) because of people like you Sumit.You would believe your country to be the best rather than take the trouble to identify the problems and solve them so that one day India really becomes the best. In this sense, Rhapsodysinger proves that he is a true patriot.
0 Stars
Brad
Albuquerque, United States
I didn't know Ghandi's Indians were the same. No moral high ground then from now, right? :)
0 Stars
Sean
Liverpool, United Kingdom
indians are very good manipulators. this article proves its beyond doubt. don't blame the west for being racists.
0 Stars
John
Dallas, United States
Bloody Indians! So virtuous!!! HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-1 Stars
Nick
Brisbane, Australia
No doubt Indians are the biggest racists. We know what they are capable of. They are just good in hiding this. They are cheats too.
-1 Stars
Adam
Brisbane, Australia
I agree. This piece comes from an Indian and vindicates what people always thought of India. They are the greatest country when it comes to racism. Dark skin colour means inferior beings. And they call us racists. This summer, thru autumn the theme had been racism between them and us.
-1 Stars
Rusty
Brisbane, Australia
Indians are the worst when it comes to racism. They just know how to manipulate things. We exposed them quite a few times in the last few months. Cheats.
0 Stars
Nkosipile
London, United Kingdom
It is just that they know how to play with words. Thanks for this eye-opener.
2 Stars
Steve
Birmingham, United Kingdom
This is a country where people burn little brides for dowry. The darker the skin, the fatter the demand for dowry. And if the poor kid's family fails to give a dowry, the child is set on fire. This is India for you folks.
2 Stars
Betty
Amsterdam, Netherlands
I never knew such a practice existed in India. This is a revelation.
0 Stars
Riedewaan
Pretoria, South Africa
SHOCKING!!!!!!!!!!! THIS CAN NEVER HAPPEN IN INDIA!!!!!!!!!!
0 Stars
Tiaan
Pretoria, South Africa
SHOCKING!!!!!!!!!!! THIS CAN NEVER HAPPEN IN INDIA!!!!!!!!!!
2 Stars
Earnest
Pretoria, South Africa
Try marketing Gandhi now. Thanks for publishing this article Instablogs. You opened our eyes. Now Indians can never claim to be a country of equals. This is a shocking revelation. Thanks Rhapsodysinger for exposing your fellow countrymen.
1 Stars
Daniel
Brisbane, Australia
It is amazing that someone from India can write such a daring piece about their own country. This is truly sensational following what we saw this summer.
-2 Stars
Pat
Sydney, Australia
Thanks Rhapsody! Indians suck. Black discriminate against black. Strange country.
0 Stars
Estefania
Hollywood, United States
This is nothing new. Talk about Gandhi now. Hypocrites.
-2 Stars
Nathan
Brisbane, Australia